Comic Book Brain

Wonder Woman 84 Review

Patty Jenkins' Sequel

What does Wonder Woman 84 remind me of? In 1944, movie producer Val Lewton made a sequel to his amazingly successful psychological horror film of 1942, Cat People. The sequel, titled Curse of the Cat People, did okay box office but was not a phenomenon like the original film which supposedly made so much money for RKO that it saved the studio from bankruptcy [1].

Unlike the earlier film which was about the maybe/maybe-not transformation of Simone Simon into and out of a female panther, Curse of the Cat People was a relatively gentle fairy tale about family dysfunction and the plight of a little girl who has something like a phantom guardian angel (Simone Simon, again as Irena Dubrovna, as in the original Cat People movie) who comforts and provides help when the tension in the movie rachets up too high. In a commercial sense, it is as if producer Val Lewton [2] deliberately sidestepped the typical sequel route and went for a tale that would have nothing to do with the expectations of his built-in audience. He was instead addressing things that he himself felt were important about children and their relationship to parents who are too busy to pay proper attention to their upbringing, which is far removed from the scare of Irena Dubrovna changing into a cat-person and slaying her enemies.

And that's the problem between Wonder Woman of 2017 and Wonder Woman 84, one is a superhero movie, the second is a quasi-superhero movie but the core is a fairy tale for kids.

Not that the film ignores comic book sensibilities. Gal Gadot has a long sequence at the beginning of the film in which she battles bad guys in a 1984-era mall, and there are other superhero heroics (with a lot of good and also not-so-convincing stuntwork) from both her and from The Cheetah (Kristen Wiig) who undergoes a transformation over the space of the movie not too much different from what is implied in Lewton's Cat People, a woman becoming a lethal feline, but the true action of the script [3] in Wonder Woman 84 is about the mystical powers of a "golden-yellow citrine gemstone" that grants wishes to whoever is holding it. It's like a genie in a bottle, and that means people want to steal it for themselves, but the necessity of gripping the rock is soon changed when not-much-of-a-villain Maxwell Lord (Pedro Pascal) uses a wish to turn himself into the "wishing stone," though he looks exactly the same afterward, but now can wield its power by getting other people to touch him and to wish for things (most of which then boosts the previously destitute Maxwell Lord's fortunes). "Be careful what you wish for" is the main underlying lesson of this movie, and there are some mentions made in the dialogue of the famous 1902 W. W. Jacob's short story The Monkey's Paw, which is about wishing for things you'd be much better off not obtaining.

Mysticism and the occult have always been either on the fringes or in the direct heart of superhero stuff, and Wonder Woman 84 is no different, and like most of the rest of the genre, no effort is made to explain where this power is coming from, whether God, gods, a Devil, devils, or whatever, instead it just is, and paying no attention to the "science" is the expectation of the writers, because the whole focus here is on how you use powers, not how or where they come from.

And that's another area where the film is questionable, with Diana Prince given a chance to live again with the dead Steve Trevor (Chris Pine) who is resurrected via using another man's body, and as Steve and Diana get to know each other again in 1984 (the previous Wonder Woman movie took place during the years of World War I), it is entirely at the expense of a hijacked body that belongs to another person whose personality and identity is apparently pushed into some unknown limbo. Eventually Steve Trevor confronts this crime (what else could it be?) and this is softly pedeled as a lesson for Diana to learn (much like the lesson in ethics given a very young Diana in the flashback sequence about an athletic event back on Diana's home island of Themyscira where she, well, cheated. A bizarre project of Wonder Woman 84 is to reduce Diana Prince instead of building her up, and the charmingly-innocent person Gal Gadot played in the previous film is almost submerged in this film into a kind of character who only functions to keep the plot moving forward.)

But it is Maxwell Lord who is given the hardest lesson (such as it is) in wishing for the wrong things, and in the conflict between his out-of-control wishing he threatens to eventually destroy the whole world. Such a tale can work either as a fairy tale or as a superhero movie, and director Jenkins does make a pretty good crisscross between the two for awhile, as long as you think this really is a fairy tale. The astonishing amount of destruction the film portrays isn't held to account against the sympathetic Maxwell, and the dead are simply unimportant and the massive property damage isn't worth a worry either. If Wonder Woman 84 was meant to be taken even partially more seriously, it would be a horror-superhero movie, and the hint of The Monkey's Paw would have been given full flower with a corpse Steve Trevor coming back to the lovelorn Diana, and the feminist avenging force of The Cheetah wreaking a brutal revenge through the Capitol of the United States. But instead, unwishing makes everything better, so nighty-night, kids.

And that is where the next-to-last of my complaints about this movie lie, how it portrays the District of Columbia. Where are all the black people? I worked and lived in Washington DC in 1984, and Jenkins' movie drastically underestimates the demographics. A lot of attention is given to the parade of fashion but outside of that a lot is wrong about the recreation of the time frame, including how it portrays street crime with people walking at dark in the wrong places in town (such as along the tidal pool area, as if the screen characters are headed home. There's no buildings down there for anyone to live in. It would be a good place to get mugged or murdered at dusk in 1984 though, if you had such an insane ambition.)

A final complaint is the length of the movie, which is simply too long. I take it that the theme is such a proud center of the project so that it got too much care and attention and swamped the story with repetition to make its points, over and over. How many times do we need to see Maxwell Lord weeping so that we finally cry 'uncle' and admit yes, he's a soulful man underneath all that greed, failure and self-embarrassment.

More recent superhero movies have been steadily moving into a goofy area where the heroes and the villains all have backstories that explain away their mad behavior and make it so that there's just isn't really anyone who is a bad-guy any longer, no matter how many people they kill. We do have an exception with the loathsome would-be assailant who assaults Kristen Wiig's character twice in Wonder Woman 84, because yes, he gets a deserved comeuppance that, as far as the film is concerned, is almost guilt-free, but then turns it on a dime when a homeless man nearby sees the interaction of The Cheetah kicking the rapist down the street and recognizes the female assailant as his day-to-day subscriber who always provides spare change, and embarrassed but hard-faced, Wiig's character stops the pummeling and exits with a warning of "mind your business," to the man she previously cared about who stands watching, perplexed. It gives us a nice gradation of the change in the character from the sweet but malfunctioning gemologist Barbara Minerva to this steadily more strident and dangerous person who is taking her place as a result of getting her wishes granted, and it fits perfectly in the fairy tale story of Wonder Woman 84, because in reality the homeless person of Washington DC in 1984 would have rushed over to rifle the pockets of The Cheetah's victim lying on the asphalt.


Wonder Woman 84 Movie Log

Wonder Woman 2017


1. RKO was in dire straits after sinking too much money into the middling-success of Citizen Kane which produced a lot of positive, to put it mildly, reviews, but not the equivalent in ticket sales.

2. Unlike the average film producer Val Lewton exercised such tight control over the making of his films it is one of the few instances where a series of movies – he made eleven for RKO – are better listed thematically and stylistically according to their producer than by their various directors and writers. Lewton actually wrote the final scripts for his films, often loaded with art direction notes, further adding to his control over the final realized product, though he made it a point to not interfere with the director on set. Lewton had a previous career as a script-doctor and literature advisor for Hollywood one-man-studio David O. Selznick. Before that Lewton was a journalist and writer, producing nine novels and one book of poetry.

3. Writer credits on the film go to Patty Jenkins, Geoff Johns, Dave Callaham and based on the characters from William Moulton Marston.


Wonder Woman 1984

Wonder Woman:

Wonder Woman

Wonder Woman 84 Movie Log

Wonder Woman 84 Review

Gal Gadot is everywhere

Wonder Woman 2017 Movie Log

Gal Gadot Wonder Woman

Lynda Carter Wonder Woman

Adrianne Palacki Wonder Woman

Wonder Woman 2017 Movie Review

A Cinematic History of Wonder Woman

Lyle Waggoner, the original TV Steve Trevor

Gal Gadot, to be or not to be Cleopatra

Wonder Woman - Gal Gadot 2017 - Amazon Streaming HD

Wonder Woman BloodlinesWonder Woman: Bloodlines

DCU: Wonder Woman Commemorative Edition MFV (Blu-ray)Wonder Woman Commemorative Edition

Comic Book Movies

The Coming Comic Book Movies 2023-2026

Superhero Movies

Top Earning Comic Book Superhero Movies

Screen Reviews

Short Review: She-Hulk, Attorney-at-Law

Fast review: Dungeons and Dragons: Honor Among Thieves

Dungeons and Dragons Honor Among Thieves – a Film with antecedents Harry Potter plus Guardians of the Galaxy plus Lord of the Rings, etc.

Fast review: Dungeons and Dragons: Honor Among Thieves

Dungeons and Dragons Honor Among Thieves – a Film with antecedents Harry Potter plus Guardians of the Galaxy plus Lord of the Rings, etc.

You will see Amazon links on this web site because I am an Amazon affiliate. I earn from qualifying purchases.

American Comic Book Chronicles: 1965-69 Hardcover from TwoMorrowsAMAZON

Overstreet Price Guide 2022-2023

Overstreet Price Guide 2022-2023

Amazing Spider-Man by Ditko and Lee from Penguin CLassics

Amazing Spider-Man by Ditko and Lee from Penguin Classics

Original Page November 2019